Have an HVAC Horror Story? Enter our sweepstakes to win big!

Book your appointment in minutes with Lucy, our automated concierge, or schedule online. Available 24/7.

Emergency Services

Contact the professionals at Wade Heating & Cooling to handle your HVAC emergency 24/7. We're available round-the-clock to fix your furnace, boiler, AC, ductless system, or geothermal HVAC. Call our team today at 412-787-1341 to get emergency service in Pittsburgh, PA, or the surrounding areas. Residential and commercial services available.

Book your appointment in minutes with Lucy, our automated concierge, or schedule online. Available 24/7.

Gas vs. Electric Furnaces: Which Is Better in Pennsylvania?

Modern high-efficiency furnace installed in a home

Is it time to replace your furnace? If it is, you may be wondering whether a gas or an electric furnace is a better fit for your home. The best option will depend on your heating needs, budget, and available utilities. Gas furnaces typically offer lower operating costs and strong heating performance during cold winters, while electric furnaces often have lower installation costs and simpler maintenance requirements.

For homeowners in Pittsburgh and surrounding Western Pennsylvania communities, winter temperatures frequently drop below freezing. Having a dependable heating system is essential for staying comfortable. Wade Heating & Cooling can help you compare your options and choose the right furnace for your home.

How Gas & Electric Furnaces Work

Both gas and electric furnace types distribute heated air through ductwork, but they generate that heat differently.

Gas Furnace Heating Process

A gas furnace burns natural gas to generate heat. The combustion process warms a heat exchanger, which transfers heat to the air circulating through your system. A blower then distributes the heated air throughout your home.

Gas furnaces can deliver powerful heating performance, making them a popular option for homes in our area as we often experience extended periods of freezing weather. To make sure a gas furnace runs safely, they require proper venting, gas connections, and regular safety inspections.

Electric Furnace Heating Process

An electric furnace uses electrical resistance heating elements instead of combustion. As electricity passes through these elements, they generate heat. A blower moves air across the heated elements and distributes warmth through your ductwork.

Electric furnaces don’t require gas lines or combustion venting, which can simplify installation. They also eliminate the risk of combustion-related carbon monoxide production within the furnace.

Comparing Furnace Installation & Operating Costs

One of the biggest considerations when comparing a gas vs. electric furnace is the difference between upfront installation expenses and long-term operating costs.

Upfront Installation Cost Factors

Electric furnaces generally cost less to purchase and install, particularly in homes with sufficient electrical capacity. Gas furnaces often have higher equipment and installation costs because they require fuel connections, combustion venting, and additional safety components.

However, installation expenses can depend on several factors, including:

  • Existing utilities: Homes with natural gas connections may have lower gas furnace installation costs.
  • Electrical capacity: Electric furnaces may require panel or circuit upgrades.
  • Equipment size: Larger homes generally need higher-capacity heating equipment.
  • Installation complexity: Ductwork modifications, venting requirements, and equipment accessibility affect labor costs.

Monthly Heating Expense Differences

Gas furnaces are often less expensive to operate than electric resistance furnaces in Pennsylvania. Natural gas typically provides heat at a lower cost than electricity, although actual expenses depend on local utility rates and household energy consumption, so it can vary.

Modern gas furnaces commonly achieve annual fuel utilization efficiency (AFUE) ratings between 80% and 98%. Electric furnaces convert nearly all the electricity they consume into heat at the point of use, but despite their high conversion efficiency, electric furnaces can have higher monthly operating costs because electricity may cost more per unit of delivered heat.

Heating Performance During Pennsylvania Winters

Western Pennsylvania experiences cold temperatures, snowfall, and extended heating seasons. Both gas and electric furnaces can keep homes comfortable, but their operating characteristics differ.

Efficiency & Cold Weather Comfort

Gas furnaces typically provide high heating output and can warm indoor spaces quickly. Electric furnaces can also maintain comfortable indoor temperatures during freezing weather.  This makes them both well suited for Pittsburgh-area homes.

Regardless of furnace type, proper equipment sizing, insulation, and ductwork condition play important roles in heating performance. An oversized or undersized furnace can lead to comfort problems and unnecessary energy consumption.

Choosing The Right Furnace Type

Neither furnace type is automatically the best choice for every Pennsylvania household. The right system depends on your home’s infrastructure and your long-term priorities.

Factors That Influence Furnace Selection

Before choosing a new furnace, consider:

  • Utility availability: Does your home have access to natural gas? If not, you may need an electric furnace.
  • Home size: Larger homes require a larger system to maintain consistent indoor temperatures.
  • Installation budget: Installation costs include equipment expenses and any necessary utility upgrades.
  • Operating costs: The expected monthly heating expenses based on local energy rates can help you decide between gas and electric.
  • Maintenance needs: Gas furnaces require combustion system inspections, while electric models have fewer combustion-related components.

A professional heating assessment can help determine which option provides the best combination of comfort, efficiency, and value.

Explore Your Furnace Installation Options with Wade Heating & Cooling

Choosing between a gas and electric furnace is an important investment in your home’s comfort. Wade Heating & Cooling helps homeowners throughout the Pittsburgh area evaluate heating equipment, compare replacement options, and find dependable solutions for Pennsylvania winters. Whether you’re considering a new installation or need professional furnace repair, our team is ready to help.

Contact Wade Heating & Cooling today to discuss your furnace installation options and schedule a professional heating consultation with our team.

Frequently Asked Questions

Gas furnaces are generally cheaper to operate in Pennsylvania because natural gas often costs less than electricity for the same amount of heat. However, your actual heating expenses depend on local utility rates, furnace efficiency, and household heating demand. For instance, if the cost of natural gas goes up, the cost to run your gas furnace will increase. 
Electric furnaces often last approximately 20 to 30 years, while gas furnaces typically last around 15 to 20 years. These are estimates, as the actual lifespan depends on equipment quality, installation, usage, and regular maintenance.
Yes, properly sized electric furnaces can effectively heat Pennsylvania homes even during extended periods of freezing weather. However, their higher electricity consumption may make them more expensive to operate than natural gas furnaces.
Financing Convenient Financing, Easy Application Learn More

Request Service

company-services company-services
Why Choose Wade Heating & Cooling?
Why Choose Wade Heating & Cooling?
Trusted Since 1982
  • Over 40 years of local experience
  • Free estimates on replacements
  • Carrier Distinguished Dealer award winner
  • 7-time Angie’s List Super Service award winner